Pastoral versus Transformational Leadership
Within the context of the churches of Christ, there is a strong vibe against the pastoral system within the denominational world. This strong anti-pastoral vibe is merely a “wording” argument because often the pulpit minister is expected to lead through a pastoral paradigm. The pastoral paradigm seeks for the minister to provide a mission of mercy as well as ministry of preaching. The minister is expected to counsel, visit the sick, and be a strong teacher of the word. Often this paradigm of ministry does not lead to growth in a congregation because these works will not compound into a growth dynamic. Most of these works, except preaching, are done on a individual basis. The works are for caring and not really leading. This is often the explanation why a minister cannot lead growth in a congregation. He is doing the wrong things and the church loves him for it. Once he begins to do the right things for growth, often the church will hate him for it. But if growth is to happen, there must be an intentional plan of action. This is why a growth calendar is called for in transformational leadership. Of course, this is found through God, by God, for the particular context of the church. The minister focuses more on the dynamics of leadership that lead to activity and mentoring of the membership more than a normal pastoral role. If you have elders, let them do it. You are an evangelist, so act like one. Often though, when people hear about an evangelist, people think “one on one Bible studies.” This is an old school method. Evangelism is much more effective through the practice of “net evangelism strategies.” You are not giving up on the “one on one,” but you are maximizing your influence and talents for a wider scope of outreach. Essentially, you are to be engaging in cultural systemic change within a congregation as a transformational leader (that is if the congregation is not growing, if it is, leave it alone). My guess that the majority of congregations need systemic change. The question is, do you know how to do this without being fired? The first step for you is to track your calendar for two weeks, what are you doing the majority of with your time? Make a list, which category are you mostly in with the works?
Related posts:
- Review of “Reconstructing Pastoral Theology”
- Popular Models in Congregtional Leadership
- Postmodernity Versus Modernity
- Church Leadership and the Growth Chart
- Read “Ultimate Leadership”














If you would like, tell me if you do, I will provide some books on this and develop this more. Also, I will provide some more help on filling your calendar up for the year. Also, I will give you some works on how to lead change in a healthy way.
Hello Matthew,
I could really use this type of information right now as I just moved into a new church with unique needs and challenges. Did you have in mind sharing this information here on your blog or more directly, say, via email.
Thanks for sharing these things,
Matthew
[...] system within the denominational world. This strong anti-pastoral. Read the original post: Pastoral versus Transformational Leadership | Musings on Spiritual … :against-the-pastoral, baitullah-mehsud, denominational, hussain-, taliban-pakistan, [...]
Next week, I will give some more specifics. I will do the first post on the reality of vision statements. How to do them and why they do not work sometimes.
Matthew,
I’m not sure there is a difference between Servant and Transformational Leadership. TL is very biblical. The four I’s fit well into the rubric of Scripture:
First of all, Jesus was a Transformational Leader and modeled all four I’s perfectly. But to find the others in Scripture I would do the following, study the following people for each I:
Inspirational Motivation: King David
Intellectual Stimulation: The Apostle Peter
Individual Consideration: The Apostle Paul
Idealized Influence: Nehemiah
I don’t think a pastor will get fired for implementing biblical principles in leadership, however it probably has happened.
Blessings,
Dave
PS: Love your blog!